paraafPeter A. van der Helm Demo link

About Teaching Research Publications Presentations



Kaleidoscopic motion and velocity illusions

Top 10 finalist in the 2007 Best Visual Illusion of the Year Contest




The illusions presented here occur in stimuli with the following layout:

Between stationary starlike inner and outer shapes, a starlike wheel rotates with constant velocity about its own center. It rotates partly behind the inner shape and partly in front of the outer shape, but at regular intervals, it precisely fills the space between the stationary shapes. At these moments, various motion and velocity illusions occur, for both the rotating wheel and the inner stationary shape.

For instance, depending on the contrasts in the image, the rotating wheel may pulsate, jolt, or accelerate, and the inner stationary shape may wiggle. These dynamic effects seem to be caused by colour assimilation and ambiguous figure-ground segregation.

For an overview with Java animations — see below
For an interactive Java exploration — see further below
Alternatively, try Michael Bach's Flash version

The required free Java software can be downloaded here

Reference
van der Helm, P. A. (2007).
Kaleidoscopic motion and velocity illusions.
Vision Research, 47, 460—465.
Abstract     Full text

Kaleidoscopic stimulus




Illusory effects for the rotating wheel

The next figure gives a schematic overview of the motion and velocity illusions for the rotating wheel, with links to animations that illustrate these effects. The effects apply to the depth configuration in the figure above with a white or black background, and are given as a function of the background contrasts of the rotating wheel and the stationary shapes.

The animations (Java popup applets) may need a few moments to get going. This can be checked in the illusion-less Animation 4 in which, both physically and perceptually, the wheel should rotate smoothly. The illusions occur in the other animations which were made exactly the same way and in which, physically, the wheel rotates just as smoothly.



Animation-1
Animation 1
Animation-2
Animation 2
Animation-5
Animation 5


Animation-7 Animation 7

Animation-8 Animation 8
Motion and velocity illusions
Animation 6 Animation-6

Animation 9 Animation-9

Animation 10 Animation-10

Animation 3 Animation-3

Animation 4 Animation-4


In both Animation 5 and Animation 6, jolts backwards can be seen to alternate with jolts forward, but the difference between these two animations is clear when viewing them side by side; the same applies to Animations 7 and 8.

Animations 9 and 10 show, apart from jolts backwards and forwards, that the background patches between the shapes seem to grow much faster than they shrink though, physically, they grow just as fast as they shrink.

Start Animation 11 to see how the illusory effects turn from one into another when contrasts change gradually.

Notice that illusory effects occur also for the inner stationary shape; for instance, it wiggles in Animations 1 and 2.



See also the 6 pairs of contrasting animations presented in the final of the 2007 Best Visual Illusion of the Year Contest.
 
Presentation of illusion
Confetti shower



Interactive exploration of the illusions

The class of kaleidoscopic motion and velocity illusions can be explored interactively in the following two ways:
  1. Launch the Java application Kaleidoscope to open a stand-alone window outside the browser.
  2. Start, inside the browser, the Java applet below.
In both cases, one may produce all sorts of illusions and illusion strengths by combining variations in:
Toggle "Inverse" to stop the clockwise rotating wheel and to let the stationary shapes rotate counterclockwise; this motion inversion helps to assess the influence of relative motion on the illusory effects in the normal situation.

Toggle "Phase" to let the wheel align alternately with only one of the stationary shapes; this helps to dissociate local effects (requiring one stationary shape) from global effects (requiring both stationary shapes). This dissociation can also be achieved by removing a stationary shape via its depth and colour settings. If the inner stationary shape is removed, one may see, as a bonus illusion, that the hole in the wheel seems to rotate independently the moment the wheel pulsates.

Toggle "Start/Stop" now and again to see, as a further bonus, motion-after effects (illusory counterclockwise rotation).


Kaleidoscopics